Compare · Updated October 2026

Echo Show vs One Button Call (and what replaced Alexa Together)

Quick answer: The Echo Show is a $180 general-purpose smart display. Amazon’s caregiver subscription, Alexa Together, was discontinued in May 2025. One Button Call locks a tablet to six big buttons managed by family, with auto-answer from approved callers and medication tracking.

We make One Button Call, so weigh our view accordingly. Amazon Echo Show details come from its public website and listings as of October 2026. Please check current pricing.

Two-year cost

One Button Call
$450
Amazon Echo Show
$180

One Button Call: yearly plan on a tablet you already own. Amazon Echo Show: ~$180.

Side by side

FeatureOne Button CallAmazon Echo Show
DeviceYour own iPad, Android or Windows tabletSmart display (Echo Show 8)
Upfront cost$0$179.99
Monthly$25, or $225/yr ($18.75/mo)$0 (Alexa+ optional)
2-year cost$450 (yearly) · $600 (monthly)~$180
Auto-answer callsYes, approved family onlyDrop In (needs permissions)
Family managersUp to 10 family membersAlexa app
Medication reminders + reportsYes: pill photos and a family-visible reported response historyVoice reminders, no reports
Music, video & readingSpotify, YouTube, web pages, PDFs, 1,000 photosUncurated
Locked down for dementiaKiosk mode, 2-tap maximumNo
CellularUse a cellular tablet or hotspotNo, Wi-Fi only
If you cancelKeep your tabletKeep device
ReviewsNew. Founding Families now enrolling.Huge review base
Choose Echo Show if…
  • Your parent is comfortable with voice assistants
  • You want smart-home control too
  • Lowest upfront cost matters most
Choose One Button Call if…
  • You need a screen that can’t be changed or confused
  • You were using Alexa Together and lost its caregiver tools
  • You want medication reminders with reports
  • You want family to manage photos, music and shows remotely

What Echo Show does well

  • Inexpensive and familiar
  • Voice control
  • Drop In can auto-connect

Where Echo Show falls short

  • Not locked down: settings, shopping and the assistant can confuse
  • Caregiver features largely gone since Alexa Together ended
  • No family-visible medication response history
  • Privacy concerns about an always-on camera

Switching from Echo Show

Looking for an Alexa Together replacement? One Button Call gives family the remote control Alexa Together offered: reminders, content, approved callers. It runs on an iPad or Android tablet instead of an Echo.

Echo Show vs One Button Call: FAQ

Is Alexa Together still available?

No. Amazon announced on May 21, 2025 that Alexa Together is no longer available and pointed customers to Alexa Emergency Assist, a call-for-help service.

Is an Echo Show good for someone with dementia?

It can work for early memory loss, but it is a general-purpose device with many settings and features that can confuse. One Button Call locks a tablet to six large buttons that family control.

Can family manage One Button Call remotely?

Yes. Up to 10 family members add photos, playlists, videos and medication reminders from any phone or computer.

Sources: Amazon: Alexa Together update (May 21, 2025)

Hear their voice this week.

Start free for 30 days on the tablet you already have. If it isn’t right for your family, you’ve lost nothing.

Start your 30-day free trial →

Your privacy choices

Essential storage remembers this choice and keeps the site working. You can change these optional settings at any time.